The Ministry of Shadows

Last Five Entries

Gone, But Not Forgotten?
Friday, Jan. 20, 2012

What The Internet Will Look Like Under SOPA
Wednesday, Jan. 18, 2012

Fearsgiving Week
Monday, Nov. 21, 2011

Jesus Approves of Waterboarding
Monday, Nov. 14, 2011

Beware of Asteroids
Wednesday, Nov. 09, 2011

Resources

FirstGov Portal

Legislative Database


Recommended Reading

Bindyree

Bruce Schneier

James Hudnall

Glenn Greenwald

D-Day

You Are Dumb


All links are current as of the date of publication. All content created by the author is copyrighted 2005-2010, except where held by the owners/publishers of parent works and/or subject materials. Any infringement of another's work is wholly unintentional. If you see something here that is yours, a polite request for removal or credit will be honored.

 

A Surge In Thinking Would Be Nice

Tuesday, Dec. 01, 2009 3:53 AM


President Obama is scheduled to give a speech at West Point this evening, announcing his decision on Afghanistan. It is expected that he will approve an additional 30,000 troops for deployment to the region.

But is this really the answer? Afghanistan has defied both the British Empire and the Soviet Union, significantly contributing to the downfall of the latter.

A 'surge' is not a strategy. It wasn't when it was prettied up with a bow and trotted out by General David Petraeus, and it isn't now that the baton's been handed to General Stanley McChrystal.

Has there really been that much of a quantum advance in fighting wars that 30,000 men can turn an untenable situation into an easy victory? We're to believe the Soviets lacked the manpower or the political will?

Just as with Iraq, we're waiting on the new government to get its act together and blossom into this wonderful example of a free and democratic nation. Yet this is Hamid Karzai's second five-year term, and there are allegations of corruption. So 30,000 troops are supposed to fix this ... how?

And is Karzai simply a victim of circumstance, condemned to play politics, or is he another example of America's busted picker when it comes to prospective foreign leaders, like Ahmad Chalabi?

But let's be honest. If we withdraw, it's Obama's fault. If we send more troops and nothing changes, it's Obama's fault, because he should have sent more. If we send more troops and we soundly defeat the Taliban remnant, it's Obama's fault because he should have acted sooner.



The Ministry has received 0 comment(s) on this topic.